Alright let me see if I can help clarify for everyone. Can you just tell us what the numbers are on each blinker? Not the VC02# but the 9 digit number followed by a - and 4 more digits.
There are three colors that look similar to both. There is a green, light blue and dark blue. The one appears to be green or light blue but honestly when I compare it doesn't quite match them. And the other dark blue for sure. I'm not saying I don't believe they didn't fade from the sun but I have never seen that before and I have had and seen many many sets of these.
In any case the # on the blinkers themself will say 100% whether one is faded or they are in fact different colors. Also, either way if they don't match they might be hard to sell for $200. These are not a rare color and that price is typically for perfect condition. Not bashing sale just informing.
P.s I might be hitting you up about a headlight harness soon.