The hub that I am having the problem with is the one that was replaced by the dealer. The ABS tone ring is a pressed on part on the axle. I spoke with the service manager and they will be replacing the axle at their cost. The tech damaged the ring when he replaced the ABS sensor and tried to blame it on a leaking boot, then a bent axle, then that the axle was to long, then that because the bearing was new when he put it back together they fit tighter than before.
Anyway, now I have to wait, because Subaru has no new axles in stock and they wont be in until Nov.11th.
thanks for your help.