If you're happy with the power and handling of your 2009 2.5i, why on earth do you want to replace it with a Legacy that's going to eat more ~$4/gal gasoline? Basically ~21mpg on average vs. 29?
As much as I love Soobs, I wouldn't touch one with a 6cyl.
Get a new 2.5i with a 6spd manual if the latest body style/features are important to you.
Last edited by PoManzAWD; 02-23-2013 at 10:01 AM..