i highly recommend final touch collision in west ny, nj.
had my front bumper refinished and resprayed on my r32, and it was flawless.
they use glasurit paint and do several layers of clear coat.
always a bunch of serious high end cars there.
ask for robert (owner) or john (staff) and say that phil's friend, victor w/ the vw r32 referred you.
a little on the higher side of what you might be expecting to pay if out of pocket, but the quality is factory.
if insurance is taking care of it, no worries.