Originally Posted by E_S_A_D
I presume the dealership is the right place to have it. They are a pure Subaru dealership and service center, I'll trust their judgements. Appreciate your info.
I suspect they will want to sell you four new tires.
I had the same thing happen to me--sidewall puncture--about 8 months ago. Ordered a shaved tire from tire rack (I think i had 9/32 tread left, although I don't remember the exact amount and can't seem to find the invoice).