Sorry I cant provide any feedback for the tires you listed, but I researched quiet tires a while back and went with General Altimax HP 225/45 on stock wheels. I haven't driven them in snow or ice yet, but they are quiet and handle rain quite well. Inexpensive also.
Just a suggestion!
*edit* I can snap a couple photos if ya wanna see them.
08 Legacy 2.5i
Last edited by bomberlegacy; 11-24-2012 at 12:43 PM..